Xero Shoes Scrambler Mid II WP Hiking Boots Review
In-depth review of these lightweight Zero Drop hiking boots and hiking shoes
Home > Gear Reviews > Footwear
June 14th, 2024
Our verdict
The Xero Shoes Scrambler Mid II Hiking Boots are the second iteration of Xero Shoes debut “hiking boot.” The original Scrambler Mid boots are breathable and feature a versatile traction option that remains sticky on rock varieties and lives up to the brand's 5,000 mile warranty. The biggest change for the Scrambler Mid II is offering a waterproof option. Plus, all Scrambler options are now PFAS-free (more on that later)!
I’ve worn the original Scrambler Mid as a day hiking shoe for hikes ranging from 2 - 15 miles on varying terrain for over a year and tested the just-released Scrambler Mid II WP shoes for over two months. Here's our verdict.
Men's
Women's
First, it's worth noting that barefoot or minimalist shoes are not for everyone, and they can take some time to get used to. But if you’re already accustomed to walking around barefoot or using zero-drop shoes of any variety, then you may enjoy a durable, comfortable barefoot hiking boot like the Xero Scrambler..
Since I gravitate towards zero-drop shoes as my go-to daily wear and beyond, the wide toe box and flat soles are ideal for me and many day hikes I pursue. I didn’t experience a break-in period with either iteration of these shoes and was able to hit the trail with them straight out of the box. While I enjoy wearing them on day hikes, I opt for a boot with more support and traction when backpacking.
Although the soles gripped well on the trail, they still performed best on well-maintained trails. Since these shoes have thinner soles and less support than traditional hiking boots, off-trail travel or exceedingly difficult terrain would be difficult, but they still perform really well for minimalist shoes on this kind of terrain.
The breathability varies depending on the style you choose. The original Scrambler is highly breathable and offers strategic ventilation. I appreciate this ventilation when hiking in hot weather, but the downside is that it allows a lot of dust and dirt to pass through. The waterproof version of the Scrambler Mid II offers better protection and decent waterproofing. I wouldn’t wade through water extensively in these boots, but I found them suitable for hiking in wetter climates and shallow river crossings.
Overall, both iterations of the Xero Scrambler Mid are an excellent choice for entry-level hikers or those who prefer barefoot shoes. You’ll feel the trail as you walk which can be a very grounding experience, but, as with other minimalist shoes, if your foot strength is not up to par, be ready for some sore feet and calves as your feet adapt.
Specs
Cushion: TrailFoam
Heel-to-Toe Drop: 0 mm
Stack Height: 11.5 mm
Lugs: 3 mm
Upper: Mesh and eVent BIO
Midsole: TrailFoam
Outsole: Michelin FiberLite Sole
Weight (pair): 20 oz (women’s 7), 24 oz (men's 9)
Comparison table of similar models
Men’s
| TRAIL RUNNING SHOE | MSRP | SIZES | WATERPROOF | HEEL TO TOE DROP (mm) | STACK HEIGHT HEEL / TOE (mm) | WEIGHT (PER SHOE) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Xero Shoes Mid Scrambler II WP | $190 | 6.5-15 | Yes | 0 | 11.5 mm | 12 oz |
| Xero Shoes Mid Scrambler II | $170 | 6.5-15 | No | 0 | 10 mm | 11.7 oz |
| Xero Shoes Scrambler Low II | $150 | 6.5-15 | No | 0 | 13.5 mm | 9.2 oz |
| Xero Shoes Scrambler Mid I | $170 | 6.5-15 | No | 0 | 12 mm | 10.9 oz |
| Altra Lone Peak 8 | $140 | 7 - 16 | No, WP exists | 0 | 25 mm | 10.7 oz |
Women’s
| WOMEN'S TRAIL RUNNING SHOE | MSRP* | SIZES | WATERPROOF | HEEL TO TOE DROP (mm) | STACK HEIGHT HEEL / TOE (mm) | WEIGHT (per shoe, oz) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Xero Shoes Mid Scrambler II WP | $190 | 5-12 | Yes | 0 | 11.5 mm | 10 oz |
| Xero Shoes Mid Scrambler II | 170 | 5-12 | No | 0 | 10 mm | 9.5 oz |
| Xero Shoes Scrambler Low | $150 | 5-12 | No | 0 | 10 mm | 7.4 oz |
| Xero Shoes Scrambler Mid I | 170 | 5-12 | No | 0 | 12 mm | 8.9 oz |
| Altra Lone Peak 8 | $140 | 5.5 - 12 | No | 0 | 25 mm | 9.2 oz |
What we liked
Meg Carney hiking in the Scrambler Mid II WP boots in central Washington. Photo by Callan Martinez.
Grippy, durable rubber with lugs that don’t collect mud
Actually surprisingly good waterproof performance
Zero drop and wide toe box for ideal comfort
Non waterproof version available (more breathable)
Details
Meg Carney hiking in the Scrambler Mid II WP boots in central Washington. Photo by Callan Martinez.
Fit
The sizing of all Xero Shoes I’ve tried, including the Z-Trail, Zelen, and Scrambler Mid, are all accurate for my feet. I gravitate towards zero-drop and wide-fit shoes, so the wide toe box is ideal for all-day comfort and helps me avoid pinched toes (and blisters).
I’ve worn the original Scrambler Mid as a day hiking shoe for hikes ranging from 2 - 15 miles on varying terrain for over a year and tested the just-released Scrambler Mid II WP shoes for over two months.
Since I am conditioned to barefoot, zero-drop shoes and the fit was suitable for my feet, I found them to need little to no break-in period with no dramatic fit changes from model to model.
They provide all-day comfort with a minimal design and roomy toe box, allowing for ample toe splay. The flexible collar and moisture-wicking lining enhance performance on the trail in wet conditions by keeping your feet dry and comfortable, but it could be a restriction when hiking in hot climates. For instance, when hiking in the waterproof version of the Mids in Sedona, AZ, my feet got really sweaty. I still chose to wear these boots due to several river crossings and to test the waterproofing.
The abrasion-resistant upper and welded sidewalls keep feet protected from debris. When a shoe has a welded sidewall, it typically means that the upper and midsole of the shoe are fused together using a welding process instead of traditional stitching or adhesives. This technique creates a seamless bond between the upper and midsole, enhancing the shoe's durability, flexibility, and water resistance.
These hiking boots perfectly fit my feet when wearing thin summer socks/liners as well as thicker wool socks, but others report running slightly oversized. Regardless, they provide flexibility and space for extended hikes without compromising fit.
Zero drop
Meg Carney wearing the original Xero Scrambler Mid hiking boots in Sedona, AZ. Like the Scrambler II, the Scrambler I is a zero drop shoe. Photo by Nina Lawson.
Zero-drop shoes are footwear designed with no height differential between the heel and the forefoot. In other words, the shoe's sole maintains a consistent level from the heel to the toe, resulting in a flat profile.
This design promotes a more natural foot position and encourages a midfoot or forefoot strike when walking or running, potentially reducing strain on the lower body and promoting better biomechanics. It's often favored by those seeking a more minimalist or barefoot-like experience, as it allows for a closer connection to the ground and a more natural gait.
However, zero-drop shoes do pose some dangers to those transitioning from traditional trail or running shoes because their feet are not strong enough to support that level of strain. Xero Shoes recommends a slow introduction to all minimalist shoes, especially for activities like running and hiking, to avoid injury and discomfort.
The zero-drop feature on the Scrambler shoes is not as visually obvious as that on their other shoes, but it still provides a grounding experience. I personally prefer zero-drop shoes like this for daily wear and short hikes, but again, my body is conditioned to that type of footwear.
Due to the zero-drop construction, you'll be more aware of debris and variations on the trail. This can be a pro or a con, as they don't provide quite the same level of protection as traditionally thick hiking soles, but shoes of this design can also help wearers become more aware of where and how they are stepping as they hike.
Cushioning
A cross section of the Xero shoe hiking boot. Photo by Liz Thomas.
Do not expect a lot of cushioning when it comes to Xero Shoe designs, including the Scrambler Mid Boots. Due to the zero-drop design, there is noticeably less cushioning than most other hiking shoe brands. The cushioning they do provide is called TrailFoam, and it is a small layer of added protection to help protect feet from hazards on the trail without compromising the zero-drop design.
When hiking, even in the desert, I did not notice any significant punctures from things like pine needles or even cactus fines. However, I could distinctly feel all the rocks and roots while walking. This is typical of a barefoot shoe design, but for backpacking, a rock plate or something similar may be beneficial, especially for extended hikes.
The minimalist cushioning design provides enough protection for well-maintained trail use without compromising the desired flexibility and feeling expected when wearing barefoot shoes.
Grip and traction
Xero Scrambler Mid II WP tread in partnership with Michelin. Photo by Meg Carney.
Thanks to their collaboration with Michelin rubber company, the Xero Shoes Scrambler Mid hiking boots deliver exceptional grip and traction for a hiking shoe. The outsole features 3 mm mud-shedding lugs inspired by high-performance mountain bike tires.
The Michelin fiberlite sole, with embedded textile layers, offers strength, flexibility, and lightness. Even on wet, rugged, rocky terrain while hiking in West Fork of Oak Creek outside of Sedona, AZ, the shoes offer a grounded, high-contact feel reminiscent of barefoot exploration. On that hike, we had over 10 different river crossings and additional hiking in the canyon stream as we approached our campsite. The rocks were extremely slippery in some areas, and I was surprised at how well the rubber performed even while wet.
Feeling everything on the trail as you walk may not be ideal for all hikers. The good news is that compared to other Xero Shoes I’ve tried (Z-Trail and Zelen), these have the best traction control on wet, rocky terrain. The lugs and tread are aggressive enough for well-maintained and moderate hikes, but they aren’t ideal for extreme terrain or extensive rock scrambling. While I felt the traction control was good in the Oak Creek scenario, I believe it is because the trail was relatively flat. On hikes in high Alpine where there is a steeper incline, such as hiking Carne Mountain or even short local hiking trails like Castle Rock, the mix of dirt and scrambling made me a bit nervous to trust my footing at times.
I do believe these soles will actually hold up for the full 5,000-mile warranty, especially since the original Scrambler Mids have lasted me over a year of hiking nearly daily.
Versatility
Meg Carney and her dog, Ash, hiking wearing the Scrambler Mid Boots in Sedona, AZ. Photo by Nina Lawson
With the release of their waterproof Scrambler option, these shoes are far more versatile for both wet and dry climates. They also offer a low-rise Scrambler if the taller upper isn’t ideal for your needs. Despite these design options, I found the versatility in terms of types of hikes these boots are suited for somewhat limited.
As mentioned, the traction is strong and does offer ample traction for most trails. However, they falter some in more strenuous backcountry terrain, and I would not trust the grip or security in some scrambling situations. These shoes may not offer the appropriate protection and traction needed for areas such as scree fields. As a result, I found them best suited for less strenuous terrain and hiking areas with designated, well-traveled trails.
Responsiveness
Meg Carney hiking in the Scrambler Mid II WP boots in central Washington. Photo by Callan Martinez.
The responsiveness of the Xero Shoes Scrambler Mid hiking boots is notable, offering a balance between protection and ground feel. While not overly cushioned, the midsole provides enough responsiveness to absorb impact without sacrificing feedback from the terrain.
This allows wearers to maintain a sense of connection with the ground, which is a good teacher for learning to navigate uneven trails. In fact, I’ve found this awareness of the ground and trail to be beneficial while hiking and prevent minor injuries like stubbed toes or ankle rolls.
The minimalistic design and the durable yet flexible outsole ensure that each step feels efficient and controlled. Whether I was tackling rocky paths or muddy terrain, especially on spring hikes in Ollalla Canyon or more remote trails in the Cascade Mountains, the Scrambler Mid hiking boots respond adeptly to the wearer's movements.
Warmth
The standard Scrambler Mid boots do not provide much warmth, but they do provide exceptional breathability. The waterproof shoes provide slightly more warmth due to lower breathability but are not warm enough for hiking in snow or cold weather. The waterproofing may help protect your feet from snow, but there is no added insulation to protect your feet from freezing temperatures.
During spring hikes in the Cascade Mountains near my home, temperatures varied between 35 and 50 degrees Fahrenheit, depending on the day, but there was still snow on the ground. Even with thick wool socks, my feet got cold after trudging around in soupy snow, and I found the waterproof boots more comfortable for warm hikes with river crossings.
Break-in time
Meg Carney wearing the original Xero Scrambler Mid hiking boots in Sedona, AZ. Both the Scrambler I and Scrambler II had no break-in period for the author. Photo by Nina Lawson.
I experienced little to no break-in period with either of the Scrambler Mid boot designs I tried. This could be because I am accustomed to zero drop, a wide toe box, and minimal cushioning.
Whatever the reason, I felt comfortable and confident hiking in them straight out of the box. Even after an initial few miles on the trail wearing new shoes, I did not experience any hot spots or blisters.
Others may need a break-in period to help their feet adapt to the zero drop, but it is not necessarily the traditional break-in we are used to with more robust hiking boots.
Waterproofing and breathability
Water levels were higher than expected on the West Fork hike, and waterproof shoes were a bad choice. Photo by Alex Wienberg.
One significant change from the original Scrambler Mid to the Mid II is a waterproof offering. The waterproofing is an eVent BIO laminate made from castor beans to create a light and flexible membrane.
The bio-based membrane used in the Scrambler Mid II WP is derived from castor beans grown in partnership with the Pragati Initiative, promoting sustainable farming practices in India while avoiding deforestation and competition with food crops. Castor, known for its drought tolerance, thrives in arid climates, providing multiple harvests yearly and boosting farmer income. Once harvested, castor beans are crushed to make castor oil, which is processed into a renewable polymer, forming the basis of the eVent BIO membrane known for its recyclability and durability against various environmental factors.
They used recycled materials and C0 chemistry (contains no carbon-fluorine bond and is a name used often to signify PFAS-free materials) to create the laminate, which means it contains no intentionally added PFAS (per- and polyflouralkyl substances). This is important to note because many companies across the outdoor industry have been working to phase out PFAS chemistry due to new regulatory standards based on health risks and pollution associated with the production of these chemicals.
That’s all well and good, but how does it work?
These boots worked just fine in wet weather and shallow stream crossings. While I haven’t had a chance to try them in winter yet, I have heard from others that even walking around in snow didn’t penetrate the membrane.
Regardless, I am always skeptical about waterproof shoes in general, but especially the performance of PFAS-free waterproofing. The waterproofing held up well during the initial tests, but I am unsure about its longevity, especially for the submersion of the boots past the laces. I was able to test the waterproofing extensively in my Oak Creek canyon hike, and when the waterline passed above the lace line, due to the venting in that area of the shoe, it was a weak spot, and as I continued to trudge through water, my feet did not stay dry. They are effective for shallow river crossings, but the lining itself didn’t seem to protect very well near the laces.
Either way, I was surprised by how well the waterproofing worked on these shoes, mainly because they chose no to include harmful chemicals like PFAS.
You can read more about PFAS in our guide All About PFAS in waterproof gear.
Durability and longevity
Xero Shoes has a lofty warranty for a shoe brand: 5,000-miles. After a few conversations with the co-founder, Steven Sashen, he reported that some customers submitted warranty claims because the shoes didn’t last the entire warranty period due to an irregular walking pattern causing more wear in one area of the sole.
I also experienced this due to an injury to my right hip with my Xero Zelen shoes but haven’t seen the same wear on the sole with the Scrambler’s. I notice far more wear on my left shoe than my right shoe because I still favor that side of my body more often while hiking.
The Michelin rubber adds to the sole's durability, but I've noticed the most significant wear area is in the upper. The upper materials on the original Scrambler are a polyester blend, and the mesh is susceptible to punctures or tears, especially if you choose to bushwhack. The upper in the Scrambler Mid II is more robust and durable, especially because of the waterproof membrane, but I want to see how it holds up with more wear and exposure to moisture.
Price and value
The price of Xero Shoes is close to that of the leading hiking boots or active wear shoes on the market. For the price, I expect the boots to last the full warranty, if not longer. Since they have excellent customer service and fulfill warranty requests when possible, I see the value in purchasing these shoes.
The durability and intentional design stand out within the shoe market, but if you are on the fence about zero-drop shoes, you may want to start with one of their lower-price options, like the Z-Trail (men's and women's).
Another option to test out if you like the Scrambler design is to opt for the original version of the shoe. At the time of writing, the original Scrambler Mid is priced at a discount at $118, while the new Scrambler Mid II is priced at $169 or, for the waterproof, $189. Keep in mind that the original Scrambler does not offer a waterproof option, while the new one has a waterproof and non-waterproof design.
Sustainability and ethical company practices
Xero Shoes is deeply committed to sustainability and ethical practices in the footwear industry. Their approach revolves around three core principles:
Build it to Last
Use Less
Source Better
These principles guide their efforts to minimize environmental impact and ensure ethical material sourcing throughout their supply chain.
One key aspect of their sustainability initiative is using renewable and recycled materials. Xero Shoes incorporates hemp, coffee, carbon fiber, and rPET (recycled polyethylene terephthalate) into their product line, reducing reliance on non-renewable resources and diverting waste from landfills.
Additionally, by using fewer components in their shoes, such as eliminating foam midsoles, they aim to decrease the environmental strain of production while maintaining durability and performance.
Transparency is another cornerstone of Xero Shoes' sustainability efforts. They openly share information about their environmental impact, including carbon emissions from operations and manufacturing. This transparency allows them to set meaningful goals for reducing their carbon footprint and continually improve their sustainability practices.
Furthermore, Xero Shoes actively engages in initiatives to extend the lifespan of their products and minimize waste. They partner with organizations like Soles4Souls to donate gently used shoes, diverting thousands of pounds from landfills each year. Reusing shoes reduces environmental impact and contributes to social welfare by providing footwear to those in need.
Overall, Xero Shoes' sustainability and ethical practices demonstrate a genuine commitment to environmental stewardship and social responsibility within the footwear industry. As with any brand, they could be better, and there is always room for improvement. Still, from conversations with representatives within their brand, they are very open to feedback and willing to grow to become a more sustainable shoe brand.
Features
Close-up on the uppers and laces on the Xero Scrambler Mid II WP. Photo by Meg Carney.
Barefoot design
On the surface, the Scrambler Mid II shoes may feel more robust than other zero-drop or barefoot shoes. This was an intentional design from Xero to help protect hikers' feet on rough terrain, and some of the sole's height comes from the 3mm lugs.
Despite a thicker sole than their other designs, it offers extensive flexibility and maintains a barefoot feel. The design features a wide toe box, allowing toes to splay naturally, and the flexible sole provides a close-to-ground feel. This minimalist approach promotes better balance, agility, and proprioception (the body's ability to sense movement and location) while encouraging a more efficient and biomechanically sound stride, but as mentioned before, it takes time to build up to wearing barefoot shoes.
Since the Scrambler boots have a slightly thicker sole than other shoe designs, they are slightly less flexible. The thickness helps the boot maintain some of the shape and integrity for hikes but also makes them a better match for things like snow shoes or winter traction like Microspikes.
Michelin soles
The Michelin soles used in the Xero Shoes Scrambler Mid hiking boots are a collaboration between Xero Shoes and Michelin, the renowned car and bike tire company.
These soles feature Michelin fiberlite technology, which provides strength, flexibility, and lightness. The soles are inspired by high-performance mountain bike tires and incorporate mud-shedding lugs for exceptional grip and traction.
Additionally, the thin profile of the Michelin soles allows for a close-to-ground feel, enhancing agility and proprioception while maintaining durability and protection against rough trails.
Vegan uppers
The vegan uppers in the Scrambler Mid hiking boots are crafted without animal-derived materials. Instead, they are made from synthetic or plant-based materials, providing a cruelty-free alternative for those who prefer vegan footwear.
Xero Shoes prioritizes sustainability and ethical sourcing in its materials, and its vegan uppers are no exception. Using synthetic or plant-based materials reduces reliance on animal products and minimizes the environmental impact of animal-derived materials.
Weight of boots
The weight of the Scrambler Mid II WP averages 12.2 oz per boot (men's 9).
The Scrambler Mid II (non-waterproof) is around 9.5 oz per shoe (Women's 7).
Lacing system
The lacing system is standard for a hiking boot. I found the laces less robust for the new Scrambler Mid II WP boots than the original Scrambler design. Instead of a rounded lace, they opted for a flat lace. The flat laces are challenging to get tight enough at times and also tend to be less durable.
They have a series of fabric loops at the base of the laces and hooks near the top of the upper, closer to the ankle. The laces are threaded through these loops and hooks in a crisscross pattern, allowing wearers to adjust the tightness and fit of the boot according to their preferences.
The boots lace to the top, but they do not get as tight as I would like. The lacing system could be improved for easier adjustments and a tighter fit when desired.
Differences from Scrambler I
Xero Scrambler Mid II WP (left) next to the Xero Scrambler Mid (right). Photo by Meg Carney.
Between the Xero Shoes Scrambler Mid I and II, several updates were made to enhance performance and durability:
Improved Upper: The Scrambler Mid II features an upgraded abrasion-resistant upper, which the company claims will provide better protection against wear and tear while maintaining breathability. I only tested the WP version of the Scrambler Mid II, and it was not very breathable. However, the original Scrambler I tested in the non-waterproof version is quite breathable, and the Mid II is available in a non-waterproof version.
Enhanced Traction: Collaborating with Michelin, the outsole of the Scrambler Mid II is designed with mud-shedding lugs inspired by high-performance mountain bike tires, offering improved grip and traction on various terrains. While the original Scramblers also used Michelin soles, the Mid II appears to be slightly more robust.
Reinforced Construction: Both versions of the Scrambler are built with welded sidewalls instead of standard stitching, providing additional durability and stability for rugged outdoor activities. However, the new waterproof version also has additional durability features due to the waterproof design.
Waterproof Option (WP): The Scrambler Mid II WP has a waterproof lining. For more details, see above.
Men's
Women's
Other models available
Xero Shoes Scrambler Low
The differences between the Xero Shoes Scrambler Mid and Low designs primarily lie in their height and ankle support:
Height: The Scrambler Mid features a higher cut that extends above the ankle, providing additional support and protection from debris and ankle rolls. On the other hand, the Scrambler Low has a lower cut, typically ending below the ankle, offering a more minimalist feel and greater freedom of movement.
Ankle Support: Due to its higher cut, the Scrambler Mid offers more ankle support and stability, making it a preferred choice for rugged terrain and longer hikes where ankle protection is crucial. In contrast, the Scrambler Low sacrifices some ankle support for a lighter, more flexible design, suitable for less demanding trails or casual wear.
Weight: The Scrambler Low tends to be lighter than the Mid version due to its lower cut and reduced material around the ankle area. This difference in weight may be more noticeable during long hikes or activities that require prolonged wear.
Aesthetics: The Mid and Low versions have slightly different aesthetics in terms of silhouette and overall appearance.
View the Xero Shoes Scrambler Low
Men's
Women's
Scrambler Mid II (non-waterproof):
Sizes: 6.5-15
Heel to toe drop: 0 mm
Stack height (heel to toe): 10 mm
Weight (per shoe): 11.7 oz
The main difference between the two versions lies in the Scrambler Mid II WP's waterproofing feature, which makes it suitable for wet conditions. The non-waterproof version offers breathability and comfort for dry-weather hiking.
Both versions share features like Michelin collaboration, lightweight construction, and thin sole design.
The major differences between the non-waterproof version and the waterproof version we tested:
Breathability: Designed to be lightweight and breathable, making them comfortable even during long hikes.
Weight: Averages 9.5 oz per shoe (women's 7) and 11.7 oz per shoe (men’s 9), ensuring lightweight flexibility and comfort during hikes.
View the Scrambler Mid II (non-waterproof)
Men's
Women's
Who should buy the Xero Scrambler II?
The Xero Scrambler II is designed for moderate hiking and mild winter wear. It’s ideal for outdoor recreationalists who enjoy barefoot shoe designs and a more minimalist feel.
The waterproof design substantially improved the durability of the upper materials and added some warmth that allows the boots to be worn in colder conditions and even in light snow. These would be an excellent option for casual hikers who stick to well-maintained trails or even as daily wear in the winter and shoulder seasons for dog walks.
What could be better
I dislike very little about the updated Scrambler Mid II WP design. I wish it could be more breathable than it is, but that wouldn't be possible for a truly waterproof shoe.
While the traction is good for less strenuous terrain, I would appreciate a slightly more tacky rubber than what is provided. The soles' durability is excellent, and if the materials had a slightly stronger grip, I would be more inclined to wear them while hiking to alpine lakes or rock scrambling.
With the improved upper materials, specifically on the waterproof design, some of the issues from the original Scrambler were remedied. I'm curious to try the non-waterproof version of the Scrambler II to see if the upper is more durable or not.
The upper itself also doesn't fit down as tight as I like while hiking, so I wouldn't opt to use these while backpacking. I prefer tighter boots that fit around my ankles and eliminate additional friction while hiking.
I would like to see Xero Shoes integrate more of a circular design into their sustainability initiatives and shoe repair options for commonly damaged areas of their shoes. They have done many great innovative things regarding footwear design, and I hope they can also find a way to utilize more natural materials when possible. I know that isn't feasible, but they could get there with more time and design trials.
Similar models / other shoes to consider
Lone Peak 8
Sizes: 7 - 16
Heel to toe drop: 0 mm
Stack height (heel to toe): 25 mm
Weight (per shoe): 10.7 oz
The Lone Peak 8 is another popular zero drop shoe. However, the stack is higher at 25 mm. It also has a rock plate, so it isn't designed to feel the ground as much. It's also about $30 more than the Scrambler. It's a good option if you want more of a traditional hiker but still zero drop.
View the Lone Peak 8
Men's
Women's
Xero Ridgeway Mesh
Sizes: 6.5 - 15
Heel to toe drop: 0 mm
Stack height (heel to toe): 12 mm
Weight (per shoe): 10 oz
The Xero Ridgeway Mesh is a low rise hiking shoe that is about $50 cheaper than the Scrambler Mid II boots. It is lighter, more stylish, but still provides a decent hiking experience. The main differences are within the sole materials and durable toe cap. The Ridgeway is also available in a waterproof model.
View the Xero Ridgeway Mesh
Men's
Women's
Xero Mesa Trail
Sizes: 6.5 - 15
Heel to toe drop: 0 mm
Stack height (heel to toe): 12 mm
Weight (per shoe): 7.8 oz
The Xero Shoes Mesa Trail is a trail running option. They have an aggressive tread and have a thicker 3.5mm foam layer for some added comfort while running. The waterproof version is also about $50 cheaper than the Scrambler Mid II WP boots and are much lighter (8 oz per shoe).
The shoe is also available as a waterproof trail running shoe, similar to the Scrambler II (men’s and women’s).
View the Xero Mesa Trail
Men's
Women's
Topo Athletic TerraVenture 4
Sizes: 8 - 15
Heel to toe drop: 3 mm
Stack height (heel to toe): 25 / 22 mm
Weight (per shoe): 10.1 oz
The Topo Athletic Terraventure 4 is a low drop (3mm) trail running shoe that provides more cushion and traction than the Scrambler Mid II would. They have a rock plate for added protection while running and are about $50 less expensive than the Scrambler Mid II WP boots.
Compare prices of the Topo Athletic TerraVenture 4
Men's
Women's
About the author / Why you should trust us
Meg Carney is an outdoor and environmental writer with a passion for environmental advocacy. She hikes daily in rain, shine, snow, and beyond (unless her PT doesn’t allow it due to injury, of course). Her time spent on the trail allows her to put in the miles needed to test hiking boots to their limit. With over eight years of gear testing experience, she’s thoroughly tested dozens or more hiking boots over the years.
Among shoes tested, she wore the Xero Scrambler Mid I for over a year and the newly released Scrambler Mid II WP for just over two months on hikes in Washington, California, and Arizona. Zero drop shoes are her go-to daily wear and preferred hiking shoe option. Beyond the Scrambler’s, she’s tested the Xero shoes, Z-trail sandal, and the Zelen running shoe.
She primarily covers topics within the outdoor industry ranging from the best new products and greenwashing to the scientific coverups of hazardous chemicals. Her work can be found in digital publications such as Field and Stream, Popular Mechanics, and GearJunkie, and her environmental journalism extends into podcast production with her original shows, Outdoor Minimalist and Forever Chemicals.
